Poly Romance Recommendations! (Because the more the merrier!)

"Puppet" is available for pre-order and will be out [12.15.24]. Following up my last post of dark romance recs, I want to share my poly romance favorites. I feel like poly romance doesn't get enough love which is a little ironic. Now to preface, I'm not including harems, reverse harems, or why chooses. Why? Because I don't like those. I like the romances where everyone falls in love with each other.

Warning: lots of smut, some dark themes, and some cheating (between eventual love interests)

[These are a mix bag of M/M/M, M/M/F}

#1: Incubus Caged by A.H. Lee

A clever woman. A powerful incubus. A sorcerer who has finally made a mistake.

When Jessica volunteered as tribute to a sorcerer's court, she knew that sex would be part of her job. However, she did not expect Lord Azrael to "feed" her to his pet incubus on her first day at work. She's shocked that the incubus--a shapeshifting panther--can take the form of a man. She's shocked that they have an audience. She's even more shocked that she likes it. When the show is over, Jessica is sent off to new adventures, but she can't stop thinking about him.

Mal, the incubus, can't stop thinking about Jessica, either. Their liaison has revealed secrets about her--secrets that even Jessica doesn't know. Mal will stop at nothing to escape from Azrael and kill him. He thinks he may be able to use Jessica to do it. However, he is rapidly developing feelings for her that he doesn't understand. Even his relationship with Azrael is changing. Can an incubus fall in love? And what will happen when he is forced to choose between love and revenge?

The Incubus Series is an MMF bisexual shifter romance with lots of steamy scenes. Adults only.

#2: The Taste of Ink by Daniel May

This one is a little tough to get through but I swear it's worth it! The cheating is between two of the love interests and is resolved between all three. There might also be some "punishment" for said adultery *winkwink*

"If he gives you everything you need, then why are you here?"

Trinket has everything he wants, and it’s not enough.

Perfect boyfriend, Siebold AKA ‘Zee,’ adores him. It took years of mutual pining to confess their feelings, and Trinket should be elated to finally have what he wanted — but the night of their confession went horribly wrong, and their relationship has yet to recover. Zee has the love, the money, and the unending patience, but it isn’t enough.

Meanwhile, tattoo artist Mini can do no wrong. From the night they met — when Trinket tried to mend his relationship with an anniversary tattoo — no taboo has been off the table.

Trinket didn’t mean to cheat.

But he also doesn’t mean to stop. For the first time in his life, he plans to get everything he needs, or lose it all trying.

Everything will change — not just for himself, but for the two men he can't possibly choose between.

The Taste of Ink is book one in a high heat, slow burn MMM trilogy with a happy ending. This trilogy was originally published as a series of seven books: A Taste of Ink, Lost in the Linework, A Guilty Canvas, A Stanza on Skin, A Darker Palette, The Color of Need, and A Final Stroke. The Taste of Ink contains content from the first three books. It has been lightly revised, with a few small changes and an extended ending in the third book.

#3: The Home-Wrecker by Sara Cate

I’ve been faithful long enough.

I never claimed to be a good man, but I’ve always done what was expected of me.

Find a nice girl. Get married. Have children.

That was my duty as a good Christian man.

And everything was going as planned when I met Briar.

Beautiful. Charismatic. Sexy.

But marriage is hard, and after seven years, I feel like I’m failing.

Then, a figure from my past enters the picture.

Dean Sheridan is cocky and charming. When this twenty-six-year-old needs a place to stay, I should turn him away—especially after I notice the spark between him and my wife. But I don’t.

When I pressure him about his relationship with Briar, he does the last thing I expect.

He dares me.

He thinks he can take what’s mine.

And if it’s a challenge he wants, it’s a challenge he’ll get.

What started as a game becomes so much more.

Between them. Between us.

This isn’t how normal couples behave.

The games we’re playing are dangerous.

And the roles we’re playing are far more.

But God help me, I can’t seem to stop.

What we’re doing is wrong, but it feels so right, and before long, I don’t recognize the good husband I used to be.

Do you want more?

Subscribe to my mailing list.

[Disclosure: This page contains Amazon affiliate links. All opinions/recommendations/reviews are honest.]